Revenue quality is how much of a company's reported revenue a buyer can expect to see again after closing. A quality of earnings (QoE) report measures it by splitting revenue into what recurs and what does not, comparing reported revenue to bank deposits, tracking which customers stayed and which left, separating price increases from volume, and testing how cash sales are recorded. Two companies with the same revenue can have very different revenue quality. The report states what the documents show in these areas, and the remaining differences, so the buyer and lender can price and size the deal on the revenue that holds up.
Earnings start with revenue, so the QoE tests revenue before it tests expenses or add-backs. Two questions apply: whether the revenue figure is accurate, and whether the revenue is likely to continue under a new owner. The QoE looks at five areas.
| Area | What the QoE tests | Main documents |
|---|---|---|
| Recurring vs one-time | Which revenue repeats by customer, contract or service line, and which came from a single event | Sales by customer, invoices, contracts |
| Deposits vs reported revenue | Whether reported revenue arrived in a company bank account | Bank statements, merchant processor statements |
| Customer churn | Which customers were lost or added, and how much revenue moved with them | Sales by customer for the full review period |
| Pricing changes | How much of the revenue change came from price and how much from volume | Price lists, invoices, unit or job counts |
| Cash sales | How cash is recorded and deposited | Point of sale reports, deposit records |
The starting point is a sales report by customer and by month for the full review period, usually the last two or three years plus the trailing twelve months. Revenue that repeats from the same customers or under the same contracts is treated as recurring. Revenue tied to a single event is listed separately with its amount and source.
Common one-time items include a large project that will not repeat, a catch-up order after a supply problem, an insurance recovery or settlement recorded as sales, a sale of equipment or inventory at the end of a product line, and government relief funds booked as income. Some of these belong outside revenue entirely. Others are real sales that a buyer should not expect again. The QoE shows them as separate lines so the reader can see revenue with and without them.
A contract does not make revenue recurring by itself. The QoE reads the terms: how long the contract runs, whether it renews or ends, whether the customer can cancel on short notice, and whether it can be assigned to a buyer. A Confidential Information Memorandum (CIM) that describes revenue as recurring is compared to what the contracts and the customer history show.
The proof of cash compares reported revenue to bank deposits month by month across the company's operating accounts. Loan proceeds, owner contributions, transfers between accounts and refunds are removed from deposits first. What is left is compared to revenue on the books, and the differences are listed. The full procedure is in proof of cash in a quality of earnings report.
For revenue quality, the monthly pattern matters as much as the annual total. Revenue that runs ahead of deposits for several months can point to sales that were invoiced but not collected. Deposits that run ahead of revenue can point to customer prepayments for work not yet done. The QoE asks the company about both and records the answers in the Q&A.
Total revenue can stay flat while the customer list under it changes. The QoE builds a customer roll forward for the review period: revenue from customers kept from the prior year, revenue lost from customers who left, and revenue from new customers.
A business that keeps most of its revenue from one year to the next has a base the buyer can plan around. A business that replaces a large share of its revenue from year to year depends on continued sales effort, and that effort may rest with the business owner. Neither pattern is a problem by itself, but they support different prices and different deal structures. When a few customers make up most of the revenue, the analysis overlaps with concentration, covered in how customer concentration affects a small business acquisition.
Revenue growth can come from more customers, more volume per customer, or higher prices. The QoE separates them where the records allow, using price lists, invoices and unit, job or visit counts. A price increase late in the review period lifts the trailing twelve months but may not have been tested against customer response for a full year. Discounts, rebates and credits are also reviewed, since revenue recorded at list price and reduced later by credits overstates what the company collects.
If the company does not track volume, the QoE says so and shows the revenue trend without a price and volume split rather than estimating one.
Cash sales are tested by comparing point of sale or register reports to cash deposits. Where they match, cash revenue is supported the same way card revenue is. Where cash is recorded but not deposited, or used to pay expenses before it reaches the bank, the QoE lists the amounts and asks what the cash paid for.
Revenue that the business owner describes but that was not recorded or deposited is not added to the analysis. It has no document behind it, and lenders do not underwrite it. The report states that it was not included.
These are round, invented numbers for illustration only. A company reports trailing twelve months revenue of $3,000,000. The CIM describes all of it as recurring.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Reported revenue, trailing twelve months | $3,000,000 |
| Less: one-time equipment installation project for a customer with no prior or later orders | (250,000) |
| Less: insurance recovery recorded as sales | (40,000) |
| Less: customer prepayment for work starting after the period | (60,000) |
| Revenue as tested, recurring | $2,650,000 |
In this example, the customer roll forward also shows that customers making up $300,000 of the prior year's revenue did not buy in the current year, and new customers added $320,000. The tested recurring revenue is $350,000 below the reported figure. The company can respond to the lines in the Q&A, and the buyer and lender see both figures with their sources.
Useful questions to raise early: whether the company can produce sales by customer by month, whether any large project or event is in the trailing twelve months, whether contracts can be assigned, when prices last changed, and how cash is handled from register to bank. The other patterns the testing turns up are covered in what red flags a quality of earnings report looks for.
The full list of procedures is on the quality of earnings page, and the revenue layout is on the sample report page. We have completed more than 600 QoE engagements and take on about 40 a month.
No. Contracted revenue is under a signed agreement. Recurring revenue repeats in practice, with or without a contract. The QoE looks at both the contract terms and the customer history.
The QoE does not set the price. It shows reported and tested revenue with the differences and their sources. How that affects price, earnouts or holdbacks is for the buyer, the lender and their advisers to decide.
No. A QoE is not an audit and gives no opinion on the financial statements. It tests revenue against outside records and lists what it finds. Legal and tax questions about your deal are for your attorney, tax adviser or lender.
Our fee is $7,500 flat for SBA-sized deals, whether or not SBA financing is used, and larger deals are scoped and priced to the work after a call, with the fee quoted before work starts. There is no hourly billing. The work generally takes two to four weeks from receipt of documents. Details are on the pricing page.