How to Choose a Quality of Earnings Provider for a Small Business Acquisition

November 11, 2026

Choosing a quality of earnings (QoE) provider for a small business acquisition comes down to a short list of questions that have checkable answers. What procedures are in scope on all engagements, and which are optional? How is the fee set, and what happens to it if the books are messy? How long does the work take from receipt of documents? Who engages the provider, and who reviews the work before it is issued? Can you see a sample report? Price and reputation matter, but two providers can both call their deliverable a QoE and do very different amounts of work. The questions below are the ones that show the difference before you sign an engagement letter.

Why does the choice of provider matter?

A QoE tests whether the earnings a buyer is paying for show up in records the business owner did not prepare: bank statements, filed tax returns and source documents for add-backs. The term has no single required scope. One provider may tie revenue to deposits month by month and test add-backs against invoices. Another may restate the profit and loss statement from the Confidential Information Memorandum (CIM) and accept the add-backs as described. Both reports can carry the same title.

The buyer, the lender and often the business owner all rely on the result. Purchase price, loan size and debt service coverage are built on the Adjusted EBITDA or SDE the report supports. A thin scope can leave a gap in the figure all of them are using. A QoE is not an audit and gives no opinion on the financial statements, so the value of the report comes from the procedures performed and how clearly the findings are stated.

What questions should you ask any QoE provider?

These questions apply to buyer-side, lender-side and sell-side engagements. The answers are facts a provider can state, not claims you have to take on trust.

QuestionWhy it mattersWhat a clear answer looks like
Which procedures are included on all engagements?Scope decides what the report can findA written list: proof of cash, tax return tie-out, add-back testing, working capital, customer analysis
Is the fee flat or hourly?Hourly fees grow when the books are disorganizedA fixed fee quoted before work starts, with what would change it stated in writing
What is the turnaround?The report often sits on the closing timelineA range measured from receipt of documents, not from signing
Who engages you on an SBA deal?On larger SBA deals the lender must be the clientA clear statement of who the engagement letter names as client
Can I see a sample report?Shows the format and depth before you payA redacted or illustrative report with the same sections you will receive
Who reviews the work before it is issued?A second reviewer catches errors in the tie-outsA named role and the reviewer's credentials
Is the work done in house?Affects quality control and confidentialityA direct yes or no, and where outsourced work goes

What should the scope include?

Ask the provider to list its procedures in writing. Four are worth confirming by name.

  • Proof of cash. Reported revenue tied to bank deposits for the review period, with transfers, loan proceeds and owner contributions separated out. This is the procedure most likely to show a difference between the books and the cash. How it works is explained in proof of cash in a quality of earnings report.
  • Tax return tie-out. Book income bridged to the filed returns line by line. A provider that only works from the internal books has not tested them against a record filed with the IRS.
  • Add-back support. Add-backs tested one by one against invoices, payroll records or other source documents, with the amount supported and any unsupported remainder listed separately.
  • A trailing twelve month view. Deals price off recent months, and interim books are less tested than filed years.

Working capital, customer concentration, owner compensation and a written question and answer log with the company are also worth confirming. If a provider describes scope only as "a review of the financials," ask what that review consists of.

How should the fee be structured?

Fees for small business QoE work vary widely, and the range is covered in how much a quality of earnings report costs. The structure of the fee matters as much as the amount.

A fixed fee quoted before work starts puts the risk of messy books on the provider. An hourly fee puts it on whoever is paying, which is often the buyer even when the lender is the client. Ask what would change a fixed fee. Common answers include additional entities, additional locations or a longer review period than first scoped. Get that answer in the engagement letter.

How long should a QoE take?

Turnaround depends mostly on how quickly the company produces documents. A provider that quotes a timeline from the signing date is quoting something it does not control. Ask for the range from receipt of a complete document set, what the provider does when documents arrive in pieces, and how open questions to the company are tracked. Ordering the QoE soon after the letter of intent keeps it off the critical path to closing.

Who engages the provider on an SBA deal?

Under SBA SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a QoE is required on Initial Acquisition and Business Expansion loans where the business purchase price is $3 million or more. The price is the figure in the purchase agreement less owner-occupied real estate at appraised value. The equity injection and any note carried back by the business owner are not deducted. The report must come from an independent financial professional engaged by and acting on behalf of the lender.

On those deals the provider question is partly the lender's. Ask your lender early which providers it uses and whether it will consider one you bring. Below $3 million, the lender or the buyer decides whether a QoE is needed and who engages it. What changes for buyers under the rule is covered in who chooses the QoE provider under the SBA rule. Confirm with your lender how the rule applies to your deal.

What should a sample report show you?

A sample report is the most direct way to see what you will receive. Look for these things:

  • A bridge from reported earnings to Adjusted EBITDA, listing the adjustments one by one with the support for them described.
  • A proof of cash table by month or by year, with differences stated as amounts.
  • A tie-out from book income to the filed tax returns.
  • Plain statements of what could not be tied to a source document, rather than estimates.
  • A question and answer log showing what was asked and what the company said.

The layout of our own report is on the sample report page, and the procedures are on the quality of earnings page.

An illustration

These are round, invented numbers for illustration only. A buyer is comparing two quotes on a business with $4,000,000 of revenue and $600,000 of Adjusted EBITDA in the CIM.

ItemProvider AProvider B
Quoted fee$6,000 estimate, hourly$9,000 fixed
Proof of cashNot includedIncluded
Tax return tie-outOptional, extra feeIncluded
Add-backsRestated from the CIMTested against source documents
TurnaroundNot statedThree weeks from documents

In this example, the books turn out to be on a cash basis with commingled personal spending. Provider A's hours run to $14,000, and adding the tax return tie-out brings the total to $16,000. Provider B's fee stays at $9,000. Provider B's testing supports $520,000 of the $600,000 Adjusted EBITDA and lists separately $80,000 of add-backs the company could not support with documents. The lower quote cost more in the end and covered fewer procedures.

Common questions

Should the provider be a CPA firm?

Ask who performs and who reviews the work, and what credentials they hold. On SBA deals of $3 million or more, the lender decides which providers it accepts. Confirm the lender's requirements before you engage anyone.

Can I use the sell-side QoE the company already has?

A sell-side QoE is engaged and paid for by the company. It can shorten the buyer's work, but it is not a report prepared for the buyer or the lender. On SBA deals of $3 million or more, it does not meet the requirement for a report engaged by the lender. Ask your lender how it treats one.

Should the same firm do the QoE and the valuation?

The SBA treats them as separate deliverables. Some lenders accept both from one firm and some do not. Ask your lender for its position early.

What are your terms?

Our fee is $7,500 flat for SBA-sized deals, whether or not SBA financing is used, and larger deals are scoped and priced to the work after a call, with the fee quoted before work starts. There is no hourly billing. The work generally takes two to four weeks from receipt of documents. Our CPA-led team has completed more than 600 QoE engagements and takes on about 40 a month. Details are on the pricing page.

How to Choose a Quality of Earnings Provider for a Small Business Acquisition

The questions to ask any QoE provider before you sign: scope, fee structure, turnaround, who engages the provider on SBA deals, the sample report and who reviews the work.

Do You Need a Quality of Earnings Report to Buy a Franchise Resale?

A franchise resale follows the same QoE rules as any acquisition. What changes is what the QoE tests: royalties, franchisor reporting, transfer fees and remodels.

What Does Revenue Quality Mean in a QoE?

Revenue quality is how much reported revenue a buyer can expect to see again. How a QoE tests recurring revenue, deposits, churn, pricing and cash sales.

What Is TTM and Why Does a QoE Test It?

TTM is the trailing twelve months of results. Why small business deals price off it, why interim books carry more risk than a filed year, and how a QoE tests it.